Main Article Content

Nadir Farid
Imtiaz Ali Langah
Mudassar Jabeen
Furqan Ullah Butt
Ahmad Arsalan Tahir
Nasir Bakhtiar
Javeria Aabid
Saad Suleman
Muhammad Rashid Waheed




Introduction: Hemorrhoids are a prevalent medical condition affecting millions worldwide, characterized by swollen and inflamed veins in the rectum or anus, leading to discomfort, pain, and sometimes bleeding during bowel movements.

Objectives: The main objective of the study is to find the comparison between closed and open hemorrhoidectomy in terms of Surgical site infection.

Material and methods: This retrospective study was conducted at Ayub teaching hospital Abbottabad from January 2023 to December 2023. Data related to surgical techniques, history of patient, demographic data and all related material were noted from the hospital record.  Demographic information, comorbidities, surgical details, operative time, perioperative management and postoperative outcomes, presence of SSIs, wound healing and complications were systematically collected and recorded.

Results: Data were collected from 230 patients according to criteria. Mean age pf patients in group A was 45.5 ± 8.2 years and 47.3 ± 7.5 years in second group. There were 120 patients in group A and 110 patients in group B. Mean operative time was 40.2 ± 10.5min and 55.8 ± 12.3 min in group A and B respectively.In the closed hemorrhoidectomy group, 8 out of 120 patients (6.7%) developed surgical site infections (SSIs), while in the open hemorrhoidectomy group, 12 out of 110 patients (10.9%) experienced SSIs. Wound healing rates were higher in the closed group (95%) compared to the open group (90%). Postoperative pain scores were lower in the closed group (mean ± SD: 3.5 ± 1.2) compared to the open group (mean ± SD: 4.2 ± 1.5).

Conclusion: It is concluded that closed hemorrhoidectomy exhibits a significantly lower incidence of surgical site infections as compared to open hemorrhoidectomy. Both techniques demonstrate comparable efficacy in terms of wound healing rates, postoperative pain scores, and length of hospital stay.

Abstract 129 | PDF Downloads 40


1. Salama MM, El Hossainy AF, Rihan M. Comparative study between stapled and open hemorrhoidectomy results with one-year follow-up. The Egyptian Journal of Surgery. 2023 Jul 1;42(3):627-34.
2. MOHAB GM, Alaa A, MOHAMED GQ, ASHRAF MA. Comparative study between Milligan Morgan and closed hemorrhoidectomy with or without plication. The Medical Journal of Cairo University. 2021 Dec 1;89(December):2253-64.
3. Kumar D, Kothari R, Thakur D, Somasekhar U, Bhukal R, Sharma D, Argal NS. Comparative study of different treatment modalities outcomes for hemorrhoidal disease. Journal of Surgical Sciences. 2021 Oct;2021.
4. Surati K, Modi J, Damani S, Prajapati K, Shah A. Comparative study of management of hemorrhoids: stapler vs open hemorrhoidectomy. Indian Journal of Sleep Medicine. 2022;15(1).
5. Alhamdany A, Rawa’a AS, Lateef NF. Ligasure™ hemorrhoidectomy versus conventional hemorrhoidectomy: comparison in outcome. Open Access Macedonian Journal of Medical Sciences. 2022 Jan 3;10(B):68-73.
6. Ahmed MF, Nada MA, Mohamed KH, Abdelrahman MO. Evaluation the Role of Harmonic Scalpel in Open and Closed Hemorrhidectomy, Comparative Study. Ain Shams Journal of Surgery. 2024 Jan 1;17(1):40-7.
7. Ruan QZ, English W, Hotouras A, Bryant C, Taylor F, Andreani S, Wexner SD, Banerjee S. A systematic review of the literature assessing the outcomes of stapled haemorrhoidopexy versus open haemorrhoidectomy. Techniques in Coloproctology. 2021 Jan;25:19-33.
8. Abd El-Wahab EH, Osman AG, Helmy M. Comparative study between pile plication technique and open hemorrhoidectomy in the management of noncomplicated second-degree and third-degree hemorrhoids. The Egyptian Journal of Surgery. 2022 Oct 1;41(4):1563-71.
9. Nada EF, Mohamed H, Mohammad H, Elhendawey EI. A Comparative Study between Stapled and Harmonic Hemorrhoidectomy for Treatment of Third-and Fourth-Degree Piles. The Egyptian Journal of Hospital Medicine. 2022 Oct 1;89(1):4985-92.
10. Arbman G, Krook H, Haapaniemi S. Closed vs. open hemorrhoidectomy--is there any difference? Dis Colon Rectum. 2000 Jan;43(1):31-4. doi: 10.1007/BF02237240. PMID: 10813120.
11. Khan ZA, Razzaq SA, Zareen NA, Hussain A, Kashif M, Khan JI. Conventional hemorrhoidectomy versus stapled hemorrhoidopexy: compare the outcomes of both techniques in patients with grade III and IV hemorrhoids. Pak J Med Health Sci. 2020;14:588-91.
12. Shah M, Makwana N, Rathwa A, Gurjar V, Maharaul HH. Comparative Study of the Stapled Hemorrhoidectomy Against Conventional Hemorrhoidectomy. International Journal of Health Sciences.(IV):2983-92.
13. Elhefny AM, Shoka AA, Elghandour AM, Hamed MA. A comparative study between stapled hemorrhoidopexy and laser hemorrhoidoplasty in the treatment of second-degree and third-degree hemorrhoids. The Egyptian Journal of Surgery. 2021 Oct 1;40(4):1046-55.
14. Selvarajan R. Efficacy of haemorrhoidectomy versus haemorrhoidectomy with internal sphincterotomy in treatment of haemorrhoids: a retrospective randomized controlled trial study. International Surgery Journal. 2021 Feb 25;8(3):839-43.
15. Prasanth Narayanan J. Role of Lateral Anal Sphincterotomy Versus Maximal Anal Dilatation in Reducing Post Operative Pain after Open Hemorrhoidectomy: A Comparative study (Doctoral dissertation, Stanley Medical College, Chennai).

Most read articles by the same author(s)

1 2 > >>