THE ROLE OF CULTURAL COMMUNICATION IN ENHANCING THE EFFECTIVENESS OF MEDICAL EMERGENCY TEAMS

Main Article Content

Faisal Ayidh Matter Alanazi
Fawaz Mofareh Lafi Alanazi
Omar Ghanem Ammash Alshammari
Faisal Mutlaq Matar Alharbi
Mansour Eid Q Alanazi
Abdulhadi Alayyat Shtit Alanazi
Hamad Alayyat Shtit Alanazi
Bader Khalaf Huwadi Alanazi
Saad Hussain Saad Alghlaidhawi
Barghash Nawaf S Alanazi

Keywords

medical emergency teams, cultural communication, language barriers

Abstract

This essay specifically focuses on exploring the role of cultural communication in enhancing the effectiveness of medical emergency teams. It is based on the observation that communication problems have been identified as one of the leading causes in root-cause analyses of adverse events and near misses. The communication problems that contribute to these adverse outcomes are not limited to language barriers, however, language barriers are an important aspect of cultural communication that can impede the transfer of critical information. Other forms of miscommunication that are affected by culture can include: the lack of articulateness in clarifying diagnostic or treatment plans; poor questioning and listening skills; inadequate explanations for the informed consent process; inadequate assessment or reassessment of a clinical problem; and condescension or hostility that can lead to ineffective assertiveness or advocacy. It is believed that the impact of all of these communications has a disproportionately negative effect on patient safety when acute medical care is required. This could be explained by the fact that the severity of an acute illness and the rapid changes in patient acuity levels necessitate high-stakes decision making and timely precise action. This is particularly true when a MET is called. At this point, patient instability has been identified and there is acknowledgment by ward staff that additional help is needed to manage the situation. High-stakes decision making and teamwork in acute situations are known to be highly influenced by culture. Decisions are based on best evidence and clinical judgment, often under time constraints. A significant proportion of medical errors in acute scenarios are attributed to errors in judgment. Experts in clinical reasoning have shown that the quality of decisions can be compromised when there is an emotional bias that is triggered by cultural differences. This is an area that has a significant effect on patient safety where we can postulate that adverse outcomes and near misses involving acute medical care may have a relationship to cultural interactions between the treating teams and the patients.

Abstract 113 | pdf Downloads 122

References

[1] Health Organization, W. "Global patient safety action plan 2021-2030: towards eliminating avoidable harm in health care." (2021). google.com
[2] Yousefian, Shiva, Sanaz Sohrabizadeh, and Katayoun Jahangiri. "Identifying the components affecting intra-organizational collaboration of health sector in disasters: Providing a conceptual framework using a systematic review." International journal of disaster risk reduction 57 (2021):102146. [HTML]
[3] Tam, I., Huang, M. Z., Patel, A., Rhee, K. E., and Fisher, E. "Spanish interpreter services for the hospitalized pediatric patient: provider and interpreter perceptions." Academic pediatrics (2020). [HTML]
[4] Rahemi, Z. and Williams, C. L. "Does ethnicity matter—cultural factors underlying older adults' end-of-life care preferences: a systematic review." Geriatric Nursing (2020). [HTML]
[5] American Occupational Therapy Association. "Educator’s guide for addressing cultural awareness, humility, and dexterity in occupational therapy curricula." The American Journal of Occupational Therapy 74, no. Supplement_3 (2020): 7413420003p1- 7413420003p19. aota.org
[6] Magaña, D. "Local voices on health care communication issues and insights on Latino cultural constructs." Hispanic Journal of Behavioral Sciences (2020). [HTML]
[7] Fox, Miriam T., Sashini K. Godage, Julia M. Kim, Carla Bossano, Sara Muñoz- Blanco, Erica Reinhardt, Linxuan Wu, Stella Karais, and Lisa Ross DeCamp. "Moving from knowledge to action: improving safety and quality of care for patients with limited English proficiency." Clinical pediatrics 59, no. 3 (2020): 266-277. [HTML]
[8] Silva, Milagros D., Stephanie Tsai, Rosanna M. Sobota, Brittany T. Abel, M. Carrington Reid, and Ronald D. Adelman. "Missed opportunities when communicating with limited English- proficient patients during end-of-life conversations: insights from Spanish- speaking and Chinese-speaking medical interpreters." Journal of pain and symptom management 59, no. 3 (2020): 694-701. sciencedirect.com
[9] Martinez, Elizabeth M., Daniel Timothy Carr, Paul C. Mullan, Lakisha E. Rogers, Wendy L. Howlett-Holley, Coleman A. McGehee, Christopher D. Mangum, and Sandip A. Godambe. "Improving equity of care for patients with limited English proficiency using quality improvement methodology." Pediatric Quality & Safety 6, no. 6 (2021): e486. lww.com
[10] Portillo, Elyse N., Anne M. Stack, Michael C. Monuteaux, Alexa Curt, Catherine Perron, and Lois K. Lee. "Association of limited English proficiency and increased pediatric emergency department revisits." Academic Emergency Medicine 28, no. 9 (2021): 1001-1011. wiley.com Foiles Sifuentes, Andriana M., Monica Robledo Cornejo, Nien Chen Li, Maira A. Castaneda-Avila, Jennifer Tjia, and Kate L. Lapane. "The role of limited English proficiency and access to health insurance and health care in the Affordable Care Act era." Health equity 4, no. 1 (2020): 509-517. liebertpub.com
[11] Jacobs, Zachary G., Priya A. Prasad, Margaret C. Fang, Yumiko Abe‐Jones, and Kirsten N. Kangelaris. "The association between limited English proficiency and sepsis mortality." Journal of hospital medicine 15, no. 3 (2020): 140-146. nih.gov
[12] Escobedo, Luis E., Lilia Cervantes, and Edward Havranek. "Barriers in healthcare for Latinx patients with limited English proficiency—a narrative review." Journal of general internal medicine 38, no. 5 (2023): 1264-1271. springer.com
[13] Khan, Alisa, H. Shonna Yin, Cindy Brach, Dionne A. Graham, Matthew W. Ramotar, David N. Williams, Nancy Spector, Christopher P. Landrigan, and Benard P. Dreyer. "Association between parent comfort with English and adverse events among hospitalized children." JAMA pediatrics 174, no. 12 (2020): e203215- e203215. jamanetwork.com
[14] Garcia, Maria E., Ladson Hinton, Steven E. Gregorich, Jennifer Livaudais-Toman, Celia Kaplan, and Leah Karliner. "Unmet mental health need among Chinese and Latino primary care patients: intersection of ethnicity, gender, and English proficiency." Journal of General Internal Medicine 35 (2020):1245-1251. springer.com
[15] Bravo, Rosana L., Ángela Gutiérrez, and Lené F. Levy‐Storms. "Patient‐Provider Relationships in an All‐Inclusive Specialized Geriatric Program: A Longitudinal Qualitative Study among Older Foreign‐Born Latinos with Multimorbidities." Journal of Elder Policy 2, no. 2 (2022): 191-214. journalofelderpolicy.org
[16] Almanzar, Anibelky, Derek Martinez, Edgar Vega, Miguel Lopez, Linda Hodes- Villamar, and John Paul Sánchez. "COVID-19 education for health professionals caring for Spanish-speaking patients." MedEdPORTAL 18 (2022): 11240. mededportal.org
[17] Nimmo, Carrie, Lyn Behnke, Constance Creech, Kathryn Schellenberg, Carman Turkelson, and Denise Cooper. "Using simulation to educate rural NP students about cultural congruence." The Journal for Nurse Practitioners 17, no. 4 (2021):