IS TOOTHPASTE NECESSARY? A STUDY ON THE ADDED BENEFIT OF DENTIFRICES ON PLAQUE REMOVAL AND GINGIVAL INDEX SCORE
Main Article Content
Keywords
Non-fluoridated toothpaste, Plaque Index, Gingival Index, Oral hygiene, Toothbrushing, Modified Bass technique
Abstract
This study aimed to evaluate whether the addition of non-fluoridated toothpaste provides any added advantage in reducing plaque and improving gingival health compared to brushing with water alone.
Methods
A randomized controlled trial was conducted at the Department of Periodontology, Sardar Begum Dental College, from April 2024 to October 2024. A total of 71 participants were randomly allocated into two groups: Group A brushed with a soft-bristle toothbrush and water only (n=35), while Group B brushed with a soft-bristle toothbrush and non-fluoridated toothpaste (n=36). All participants were instructed in the modified Bass technique using a model. Plaque Index (PI) and Gingival Index (GI) were recorded at baseline and after two weeks. Data were analyzed using paired and independent t-tests, with p < 0.05 considered statistically significant.
Results: Both groups showed significant reductions in plaque and gingival scores after two weeks of brushing (p < 0.05 for intragroup comparisons). However, intergroup analysis revealed no significant difference between the brush-only group and the brush + non-fluoridated toothpaste group for either PI (p = 0.81) or GI (p = 0.76). Percentage reductions were comparable across groups, indicating similar efficacy.
Conclusion
The findings suggest that the mechanical action of toothbrushing, when performed using proper technique, is the key factor in plaque control and gingival health improvement. The use of non-fluoridated toothpaste did not provide any additional benefit beyond brushing with water.
References
2. Marçal FF, Mota de Paulo JP, Barreto LG, de Carvalho Guerra LM, Silva PGdBJIJoDH. Effectiveness of orthodontic toothbrush versus conventional toothbrush on plaque and gingival index reduction: A systematic review and meta‐analysis. 2022;20(1):87-99.
3. Taschieri S, Tumedei M, Francetti L, Corbella S, Del Fabbro MJJoE-BDP. Efficacy of 67% sodium bicarbonate toothpaste for plaque and gingivitis control: a systematic review and meta-analysis. 2022;22(2):101709.
4. Suresh S, Arumugham IM, Doraikannan S, Rathinavelu PK, Prabakar J, Balasubramaniam AJJoISoP, et al. Comparing the effectiveness of herbal and conventional dentifrices in reducing dental plaque and gingivitis: a systematic review. 2021;11(6):601-8.
5. Martinez A, Im J, Bezman E, Lee E, de Anda D, Ree R, et al. A comparison of toothpaste tablets and a sodium fluoride dentifrice for the control of supragingival plaque and gingivitis: A 2-week randomized controlled trial. 2023;36(4):172-6.
6. Valkenburg C, Else Slot D, Van der Weijden GJIJoDH. What is the effect of active ingredients in dentifrice on inhibiting the regrowth of overnight plaque? A systematic review. 2020;18(2):128-41.
7. Machorowska-Pieniążek A, Morawiec T, Olek M, Mertas A, Aebisher D, Bartusik-Aebisher D, et al. Advantages of using toothpaste containing propolis and plant oils for gingivitis prevention and oral cavity hygiene in cleft lip/palate patients. 2021;142:111992.
8. Paqué PN, Schmidlin PR, Wiedemeier DB, Wegehaupt FJ, Burrer PD, Körner P, et al. Toothpastes with enzymes support gum health and reduce plaque formation. 2021;18(2):835.
9. Daly S, Seong J, Parkinson C, Newcombe R, Claydon N, West NJJoD. A randomised controlled trial evaluating the impact of oral health advice on gingival health using intra oral images combined with a gingivitis specific toothpaste. 2023;131:104472.
10. Janakiram C, Venkitachalam R, Fontelo P, Iafolla TJ, Dye BAJBcm, therapies. Effectiveness of herbal oral care products in reducing dental plaque & gingivitis–a systematic review and meta-analysis. 2020;20(1):43.
11. Subramanya AP, Prabhuji V, Vardhan KB, Mlv PJIJoDH. Comparative evaluation of efficacy of enzymatic toothpaste over standard fluoridated toothpaste in reduction of plaque and gingivitis. 2021;19(2):231-6.
12. Mahmood U, Memon F, Raffi S, Imran MF, Shah SSH, Zahid FJPJoM, et al. Comparative Efficacy of Herbal vs Fluoride Toothpastes in Reducing Plaque Index and Gingival Bleeding. 2023;17(12):302-.
13. Ramesh M-V, Allamaprabhu C, Kumar N-N, Yasmeen S-A, Praveen G, Lakshmi T-V-SJJoC, et al. Evaluation of dentifrices of complementary and alternative medicinal systems on plaque formation and gingivitis: A randomized controlled clinical trial. 2020;12(3):e227.
14. Pentapati K-C, Kukkamalla MA, Siddiq H, Sabnis NJJot, medicine c. Effectiveness of novel herbal dentifrice in control of plaque, gingivitis, and halitosis–Randomized controlled trial. 2020;10(6):565-9.
15. Lile IE, Osser G, Negruţiu BM, Valea CN, Vaida LL, Marian D, et al. The structures–reactivity relationship on dental plaque and natural products. 2023;13(16):9111.
16. Mason S, Patil P, Karad VJOH, Dentistry P. A randomised clinical study to evaluate efficacy on gingival health of 62% and 67% sodium bicarbonate toothpastes. 2021;19:b2403125.
17. Labib ME, Perazzo A, Manganaro J, Tabani Y, Milleman KR, Milleman JL, et al. Clinical assessment of plaque removal using a novel dentifrice containing cellulose microfibrils. 2023;12(1):7.
18. Milleman J, Bosma ML, McGuire JA, Sunkara A, McAdoo K, DelSasso A, et al. Comparative effectiveness of toothbrushing, flossing and mouthrinse regimens on plaque and gingivitis: a 12-week virtually supervised clinical trial. 2022;96(3):21-34.
19. Geisinger ML, Geurs NC, Novy B, Otomo‐Corgel J, Cobb CM, Jacobsen PL, et al. A randomized double‐blind clinical trial evaluating comparative plaque and gingival health associated with commercially available stannous fluoride‐containing dentifrices as compared to a sodium fluoride control dentifrice. 2023;94(9):1112-21.
20. Rajendiran M, Trivedi HM, Chen D, Gajendrareddy P, Chen LJM. Recent development of active ingredients in mouthwashes and toothpastes for periodontal diseases. 2021;26(7):2001.
Article Sidebar
Article Details
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
All articles published in JPTCP are licensed under Copyright Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
Dr Wajiha Khan
BDS, FCPS, Senior Registrar, Department of Periodontology, Sardar Begum Dental College and Hospital, Peshawar, Pakistan
Dr Sabahatullah
BDS, House Officer, Department of Periodontology, Sardar Begum Dental College and Hospital. Peshawar, Pakistan
Dr Farooq Maqsood
BDS, FCPS, Assistant Professor, Department of Periodontology, Shifa College of Dentistry Islamabad, Pakistan